Ask Bill your personal finance question

Shopping for a FHA Streamline with a Low Credit Score

Can I find a lender for a FHA streamline refinance if I have a low credit score?

My wife and I are trying to do a FHA Streamline Ref. We have a FHA loan through VHDA (Virginia). We have lived in this house for 5 yrs and never once been late. We want to take advantage. of the low interest rates. So we contacted our mortgage broker to start the FHA SL Ref. He said we were not able to do so because my wife's credit has fell below the 620 score requirement. We don't know what to do. This seems unfair considering we have no problem paying the current mortgage payments. Household income $100-120k. Please HELP

Read full question
Bill's Answer
4.5
/5.0
(8 Votes)

FHA Streamline Refinance - Low Credit Score?
Highlights

  • FHA Streamline Refinance allows for low credit scores.
  • Many lenders have additional stricter requirements.
  • Shop around for a niche lender.

Thank you for your question about FHA Streamline Refinance and credit scores.

The FHA streamline refinance loan program was designed to help FHA loan borrowers refinance their loans in order to lower their interest rates, lower their payments, and/or move to a stable loan. For example move from an ARM (Adjustable Rate Mortgage) to a FRM (Fixed Rate Mortgage).

Just recently, the FHA, under President Obama's directive, lowered the MIP (mortgage insurance premium rates) on FHA streamline refinance loans. (Note: The rates for regular FHA loans were increased).

In order to help you find a FHA loan take the following steps, learn about:

  1.  Basic Eligibility and Costs
  2.  Lender's FHA Credit and other Extra Requirements
  3. FHA Streamline - Shopping Around

FHA Streamline Loans - The Basic Requirements

In order to be eligible for a FHA loan, you need to meet the following basic requirements:

  • Current loan is a FHA loan
  • You are current in your payments
  • You have a tangible benefit, usually through lower  monthly interest and principal payments.

In general the FHA streamline loan does not require:

  • An appraisal on the property. Even if an appraisal is used and it hurts the borrowers chance to refinance, the lender can disregard the appraisal. In effect the FHA streamline refinance allows for an unlimited LTV.
  • A credit report. In general this is not required, unless the loan is a "credit qualifying loan".
  • A minimum credit score. If it exists,a credit score must be entered,in the underwriting system for each borrower.
  • Employment or income verification.

However,  a FHA streamline loan does require a "net tangible benefit",  which is defined as lowering your monthly mortgage payment (principal, interest, and mortage insurance payment) by more than 5%.

More stringent credit requirements (or a "credit qualifying loan") exist for a FHA streamline refinance loan including:

  1. verification of borrower's credit report and income.
  2. computation of DTI ratios
  3. evaluation that the borrower can meet the new mortgage payments.

There are several technical reasons for a loan to be defined as a "credit qualifying loan" including terms of assumption of a loan, and deletion of a borrower. However, one of the main reasons is if the new mortgage term will cause an increase of more than 20% in the mortgage payment.

In general most borrowers who have held the loan for more than 6 months are eligible for a FHA streamline refinance loan. Note: You must have made at least 6 payments and at least 210 days have elapsed since closing on the current FHA loan.

June 2012 Update

The FHA streamline refinance MIP, for original FHA insured loans originated before June 2009, recently decreased. Upfront MIP is only 0.1%. Annual MIP is only 0.55%.

FHA Streamline Refinance Loan - Extra Requirements

Update

According to a new reports from National Mortgage News the biggest lenders including, Wells Fargo, PHH Mortgage, and JP Morgan Chase (JPM) began in June 2012 to only do FHA streamline loans that they are currently servicing. It is estimated that Wells Fargo and JPM have a combined market share of 47% of FHA loans.

You have already experienced the effects of lenders stricter underwriting requirements. Although  the FHA loan was designed to allow an easy process with no LTV, employment, credit or income requirements, the HUD underwriting guidelines do allow for the lender to apply stricter requirements (or overlays).

One of the more common overlays is the credit score requirement. Although FHA loans have easier credit score requirements, many lenders require a score over 580 or 620. The same tougher overlays is true for FHA streamline loans. In fact, many lenders (such as Quicken Loans Feb 2012 policy) require at least a 640 FICO score, not just the 620 score your wife has.

Getting a FHA Streamline Loan

Your situation is frustrating, especially since the Obama Administration is trying to get the lenders to help underwater and struggling borrowers make their loans more affordable. The goal is to lower your costs, stabilize the housing market, and put more dollars in the economy.

However, your situation is not without hope. I suggest that you take these steps:

  1. Continue to make your mortgage payments on time.
  2. Improve your credit scores. Your wife's credit score can be rebuilt, although this does take time. Monitor your reports, dispute incorrect negative items, and do pay for deletes if possible on negative entries.
  3. Explain to the lender any compensating factors, including assets, savings or higher income (lower DTI).
  4. Shop around. Since your current lender, VHDA, is not doing refinance loans, you need to seriously shop around. There are niche lenders that provide FHA streamline refinance loans with lower FICO score.

Quick tip

Shop around and get a free mortgage quote for a FHA streamline refinance loan from one of Bills.com mortgage providers.