Effects on Credit of Co-signing for a Loan

How will co-signing on a loan affect my credit rating and my ability to get other loans for myself?

Read full question
Bill's Answer: Bills.com Resident Expert

You ask excellent questions about the risks of co-signing on a loan.

The Co-Signer and Financial Responsibility

Although you may want to help a family member or friend who cannot qualify for the loan without a co-signer, it is important for you to understand what your obligations are when you co-sign on a loan. When you co-sign a loan, you take responsibility for repaying the loan if the primary borrower does not. This means you may repay the loan plus any late fees, interest, or other charges the lender has added if the lender cannot collect from the borrower.

FTC Rules About Co-Signing

According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), a co-signer must be presented with a detailed disclosure by the lender before he or she co-signs for the loan that explains the co-signer's obligations.

The disclosure reads, "You are being asked to guarantee this debt. Think carefully before you do. If the borrower does not pay the debt, you will have to. Be sure you can afford to pay if you have to, and that you want to accept this responsibility.

"You may have to pay up to the full amount of the debt if the borrower does not pay. You may also have to pay late fees or collection costs, which increase this amount.

"The creditor can collect this debt from you without first trying to collect from the borrower. (Depending on your state, this may not apply. If state law forbids a creditor from collecting from a cosigner without first trying to collect from the primary debtor, this sentence may be crossed out or omitted altogether.) The creditor can use the same collection methods against you that can be used against the borrower, such as suing you, garnishing your wages, etc. If this debt is ever in default, that fact may become a part of your credit record.

"This notice is not the contract that makes you liable for the debt."

As the disclosure explains, the co-signer is exposed to a lot of potential financial harm. Remember, even if the person you co-sign for has every desire and intention to repay the debt, if circumstances arise that make his/her repaying impossible, the co-signer is on the hook. Loss of income or job, an illness, or some other unforeseen event could impede the person's ability to pay, leaving the co-signer the only with means to pay it back and fully liable to do so.

According to the FTC, "Studies of certain types of lenders show that for cosigned loans that go into default, as many as three out of four cosigners are asked to repay the loan." The only reason the borrower is being asked for a co-signer is that the lender decided that the risk was too great to offer the loan without one. Sometimes, this is not due to the borrower having a poor credit history of bad payments, but due to the fact that the borrower has never had credit before. Having a loan co-signed for, if the loan is paid back as agreed, is a great way for a person without credit to establish credit worthiness, though that does not lessen the co-signer's responsibility in any way.

The Effect on Credit for the Co-Signer

Another impact you asked about was effect on the co-signer's credit. There are two main effects. First, it will appear on your credit report, much like any other debt. If payment is late, for instance, that derogatory notation will appear on the your credit report, lowering your credit score. This can happen well before the co-signer has any idea that there is a problem, as the co-signer does not often receive a monthly billing statement.

Secondly, because the co-signed loan shows on the co-signer's credit report, it may prevent the co-signer from obtaining credit. If a co-signer is planning to buy a house, car, or other large purchase during the life of the co-signed loan, it is a good idea to think about the implications. For instance, it is prudent to consider whether the co-signed loan would negatively affect the co-signer's debt to income ratio and be a reason for not qualifying for the desired loan, even if all payments are made on time on the co-signed loan.

If You Decide to Co-Sign

Despite the risks involved, a person may decide to co-sign a loan, to help out a friend or family member. If the decision is made to co-sign, here are some things to keep in mind.

  1. Be certain that you can afford to make the payment on the loan, while maintaining your other financial obligations. If you cannot, you increase the risks that you could end up suffering collection efforts, including a wage garnishment, along with your credit rating suffering.
  2. If you are asked to pledge anything as security, such as a home or car, be aware that you could lose the asset, if the borrower defaults and you are not able to pay back the loan.
  3. You can make certain requests from the lender, which can offer you a degree of protection, though the lender does not have to grant them. For instance, you can ask the lender to make it so that you are responsible only for the principal of the loan, so you are not liable for late charges and collection fees. You can also ask that the lender notify you if a payment is late, so you can try to fix the problem before it gets out of hand and hurts you. In either of these cases, get the assurance from the lender in writing, or it is not going to help you.
  4. Keep all the records and paperwork associated with the loan. This way, if there is any dispute, you have records. Because the lender is not required to give these records to you, make sure to get copies from the borrower.
  5. Because rules can vary from State to State, check with the consumer rights department in your State of residence.

The FTC details facts for consumers about co-signing.

I hope this information helps you Find. Learn & Save.

Best,

Bill

Bills.com

Comments (40)


Michael B.
Kansas City, MO  |  April 24, 2012
I plan on financing a car in the summer. I just graduated with my Master's and will begin my job in June. My credit is very bad (had a tough time with credit cards during my undergrad, but are all paid, but my credit is still very bad). My brother agreed to cosign because he knows I would get a better rate with his excellent credit. He doesn't know about my horrible, horrible credit and he just figures that getting out of school, I will have average/ below average credit, so he is willing to help me out with a better rate. Since my undergrad financial fiasco, I have been very responsible with money, owe no money (besides some student loans) and own no credit cards. I have 30% for a down payment saved up and will have a full-time, well paying job so there will be no problem paying for the car. Basically, I want to know if my brother will be informed of my bad credit history/ horrible credit score when he does cosign. I am embarrassed and ashamed to tell him the truth about my past experience with money.
Bills.com
April 24, 2012
Co-signers on credit cards do not see the other's credit report or score as a matter of course. I do not know if that is customary for vehicle finance companies, banks, or credit unions, but I would be surprised if it was.

My advice? Come clean with your co-signer. You need not reveal all of the gory details, but you can say, "I got in over my head with credit cards, and had some late payments, but all of my cards have either been paid off or current since (the date you got it together) and I learned my lesson." Or words to that effect. We all screw up at something at some point in our lives. It's embarrassing at the time, and sometimes we need the help of our family and friends to work through the consequences. But if you learn, admit your mistake, and don't repeat it, our friends and family forgive and forget.
Mario G.
El Mirage, CA  |  April 21, 2012
I co-signed for some furniture for a friend for the amount of $3,000. He didn't pay. This has gone on for four years when I tried to get a loan to lower my interest rate on my car loan, that popped up. He called the collection agency and settled for a lesser amount. How will this affect my credit? I'm really worried. I was really looking forward to buying a house and this has set me back. I hope you can help guide me in the right direction.
Bills.com
April 25, 2012
When you co-signed, you took full financial responsibility for the debt. The derogatory account harms your credit. Depending on what else shows on your report, it could have harmed your score enough to delay a home purchase for a while.

The fact that the debt is now at $0 balance is good for two reasons. One, you won't face any collection efforts. Two, a paid-off collection account is better for your credit than one with a balance owing.

Right now, you just need to take basic steps to improve your credit score.
Jess M.
San Bernardino, CA  |  April 20, 2012
I have a car loan, Im the buyer of the car but I have a co-buyer. The co-buyer wants to purchase a home and is asking me to provide proof that I'm paying for the car loan to provide it to the underwritter. Is a bank statement the only document that can prove that I'm paying for the loan and not the co-buyer?
Bills.com
April 20, 2012
What your co-borrower needs is a way to show his/her underwriter that the debt should not be included in any debt-to-income calculations. You need to show that you're making the payments. In addition to bank statements, you could use cancelled checks or money order receipts, depending on how you make payment. If you pay cash, you create a higher burden of proof. Perhaps you can make a legal declaration that you make the payment? Have your co-borrower speak to the loan officer, to find out what the underwriter will accept.
Kay H.
Macomb, IL  |  April 09, 2012
I need to take out a small student loan of $1000 from my bank but I do not make enough so I need a co-signer. My friend has offered to cosign for me but my question she plans on taking out her own student loans herself for fall and I am wondering whether her cosigning for me could affect the amount or chance of her receiving her student loans?
Bills.com
April 10, 2012
The monthly payment for your student loan, for which your friend is fully responsible, will be figured into her debt-to-income ratio (DTI). How the payment affects her DTI is the only issue that should affect her qualifying for another loan.
Rolando L.
La Grulla, TX  |  March 23, 2012
If I co-signed a car for my friend but they put me as the primary buyer and her the secondary and when is she able to refinance and will it affect my credit score?
Bills.com
March 23, 2012
  1. Your co-signer will be able to refinance when he or she meets a lender's minimum standards for
    • Income history
    • Credit score
    • Debt-to-income ratio
  2. Your friend refinancing will probably not change your credit score. However, you will be able to qualify for more or different loans because your debt-to-income ratio will change.

See the Bills.com resource Car Loan Refinance to learn more.

Michell N.
Attica, OH  |  February 28, 2012
My son has defalted on his student loans, and i have co signed them. He now has a job and is making monthly payments. How long will it take till my credit rating gos back up?
Bills.com
February 28, 2012
Unfortunately, the answer is not so simple. Each credit bureau has different ways of arriving at their score. However, the main components in a credit score are timely payments, credit utilization and a good mix.

Also, what you have in god standing on your credit report and how high your score currently is will influence how far your score drops and how quickly it rebounds. I recommend that you continue to monitor your credit report.
Elizabeth C.
New Albany, IN  |  February 25, 2012
My mom is wanting to co-sign for me to get a newer car. Her credit is great, but mine isn't so hot. If all the payments are made on time, will that help boost my credit along with hers? Or will it just help her credit?
Bills.com
February 25, 2012
Co-signing carries the risk for the "good" borrower, if payments are late, by harming both parties credit score. However,getting a loan with a co-signer is a good way to improve your credit score, as long as the payments are made on time.
I recommend that you read the Bills.com article credit answers to learn more about credit scores and how to monitor them.
John R.
Cumming, GA  |  February 14, 2012
If one who has excellent credit co-signs a note for purchase of a truck for secondary co-signer who has no credit history whatsoever, will final payment and discarge of the note be reflected in the secondary co-signer's credit report? How might the paid off truck loan be treated as a credit score where the secondary co-signer uses a secured credit card where purchases are sent by the issuer to the credit bureaus?
Bills.com
February 14, 2012
Some credit score-related questions are difficult to answer authoritatively because the companies that write the credit score software release limited information about how their algorithms work. Anecdotally, we can say that credit scoring software treats a co-signed tradeline as if each co-signer is the only signer on the account. This means that if Co-signer A starts with a high 700 score, and Co-signer B has a 500 score and the account becomes delinquent, Co-signer A will see more damage to their score than B. Similarly, the benefit to both A and B for the co-signed loan will be in accordance with A and B's starting point. If A is already in the 700s, he or she will see a smaller boost than will B.

How the loan is paid — check, money order, wire transfer, ACH — is irrelevant for credit scoring purposes. What matters is if payments are timely.
Noemi P.
Colorado Springs, CO  |  February 10, 2012
Hi, I am co-signing for my brother to help get a better credit. My question is, how soon can he refinance the car so I can be removed from the contract?
Bills.com
February 10, 2012
The primary borrower may refinance as soon as his credit history and financial picture improves to the point that lenders believe he is an acceptable credit risk.
John A.
December 27, 2011
Hey I'm still not clear as to whether or not the actual act of cosigning will hurt my credit. I'm aware that if I cosign and the borrower negates on payments and whatnot, it may lead to a negative towards my credit. But will just having (in this case $3,000) this debt lower my score immediately? Thanks for your time
Bills.com
December 27, 2011
It is impossible to know how taking extra credit will immediately affect your credit score, which is made up of five factors. Read the Bills.com article about understanding your credit score. You will want to monitor your credit report and your credit score.

Cosigning a loan is like taking a loan yourself. It will affect your credit mix, your total debt, and possibly your total available balance. Cosigning could even improve your credit score. The most important thing to remember is that you will be responsible for the loan, and if anything goes wrong, your credit score will be negatively affected, and even more important you will be liable to pay the whole loan and face aggressive collection efforts if unable to pay as agreed.
Waiting for comments to load Loading more comments
Thanks for your feedback!

Get a Credit Card or Credit Score

 
Thank you for subscribing!