Ask Bill your personal finance question

Will Paying-Off Collection Accounts Increase My Credit Score

Will my credit score improve if I pay off my collection accounts?

I am trying to fix my credit. I have several accounts that have been sent to a collection company. If I pay off these accounts will it improve my credit score? Will they stay on my report as a collection account, but show that they were paid? Will they stay on my report for 7 years from the date that the account was sent to the collection agency, or from the date they were paid?

Read full question
Bill's Answer
167 Comments
4.0
/5.0
(23 Votes)

Updated: Dec 15, 2013

Improve Credit Score
Highlights

  • Examine how paying off collections accounts affects your credit score.
  • Understand the benefits of paying off old debt, aside from the effects on your credit score.

Should you pay a collection account? Great question! Before we get to your question, let’s define some words and phrases collection agents use, and talk about three issues you need to think about before taking any action.

If you have an unpaid debt, you may wish it just goes away. But original creditors and collection agents see unpaid debts as assets. Like almost any other asset, an unpaid debt can be bought, sold, or traded. Debt collectors and original creditors call bad debts “collection accounts.”

Your collection account can appear more than once on your credit report. Its history will start with the original creditor, and then reappear on your credit report as collection agents buy, sell, and trade your account. Your collection accounts may move through many collection agencies, and your credit report will show this chain of ownership.

What’s a Derogatory?

The credit bureaus — Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion — call collection accounts “derogatories.” Derogatories are negative accounts that drag down your credit score. Most collection accounts and other derogatories are allowed to appear on your credit report for 7 years. The starting point for the 7-year rule is the date of first delinquency. In other words, the 7-year clock starts when you miss your first payment.

Just because something appears on your credit report does not make it a fact. Review your credit reports once a year to dispute errors that harm your credit score.

Dishonest collection agents change the date of first delinquency to a later date. This violates federal law. They do this, it seems, to make a collection account appear longer on your credit report, thinking its lengthy appearance will add pressure for you to pay the debt.

Pay or Ignore a Collection Account?

You may wonder if it is worth your while to pay a collection account. Let’s look at this question from three different angles:

  1. Your state’s statute of limitations
  2. The credit report 7-year rule
  3. A collection account’s impact on your credit score

Let’s get some misinformation out of the way first. You may read statements from some who say, “You don’t have a legal obligation to pay a collection agent anything because you never had a contract with the collection agent.” This argument doesn’t hold water. Original creditors reserve the right to sell their collection accounts. This gives the collection agent who buys your collection account the legal right to collect the face value of the debt. You may have some other reason you do not need to pay an old collection account, but it won’t be due to this bogus argument.

1) Statute of Limitations

A statute of limitation is a time limit. Once the statute of limitations clock runs out on a crime, for example, the district attorney can no longer charge anyone with the crime. Statutes of limitations for debt are a bit different and more complicated.

For debt, the statute of limitations is a civil matter. Being in debt is not a crime. When someone files a civil lawsuit against you, always look at the statute of limitations. If the statute of limitations clock has run out, then you can file a motion with the court that says, “Hey, everything here might be true, but because the clock has run out, the court must dismiss the case.”

Statute of limitations rules can get tricky if you sign a contract in one state then move to another, or if you and the other party reside in different states. Read the Bills.com article How to Tell Which Statute of Limitations Applies to You if your facts are complicated.

Every state’s statute of limitations rules vary. Learn your state's statute of limitations rules for the type of debt in your collection account. If your state’s statute of limitations clock on your collection account has run out or is about to run out, you can use this to your advantage. More about this later.

If your collection account’s statute of limitations clock has expired, you have no legal obligation to pay the debt. If your collection account’s statute of limitations clock as run out, a collection agent cannot use a lawsuit threat to try to convince you it’s serious about collecting the debt. Any threat of this kind is not only hollow, it is also illegal.

Two confusing things about statutes of limitation and collection accounts trip-up many people:

  • An expired statute of limitations clock does not prevent lawsuits. Some original creditors and collection agents file lawsuits against consumers even though the statute of limitations clock has expired. This is legal in all but two states. You may wonder why someone would file a lawsuit they know could be defeated so easily. Many consumers do not understand statutes of limitations laws, or bother to hire lawyers to defend them. This is unfortunate, but consumers who do not defend themselves lose by default. Consult with a lawyer if you receive a written notice of a lawsuit.
  • The statute of limitations clock is separate from the 7-year credit report clock. Some state statutes of limitations are shorter than 7 years, but some are longer. Keep these two clocks separate in your mind because they are for separate things.

2) The Credit Report 7-Year Rule

As mentioned above, most collection accounts can appear on your credit report for 7 years. Collection agents cannot change the date of first delinquency to make the collection account appear for more than 7 years.

The 7-year rule can be found in the Fair Credit Reporting Act, a federal law that sets the rules for credit reports and the companies that create this information, including Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion.

Dishonest collection agents will claim that as long as the collection account appears on your credit report, you have a legal obligation to pay the debt. That’s not true.

If the 7-year clock on your collection account is about to run out, you can use this to your advantage. More about this later.

3) Credit Scores & Collection Accounts

A collection account harms your credit score as long as it appears on your credit report. However, credit score software like FICO and VantageScore put less and less weight on a derogatory the longer it appears on your credit report. A fresh collection account harms your credit score more than one that is 6 years old.

Generally, credit scoring software does not reward or punish you for paying off an old collection account. Your credit score is damaged when a creditor reports negative things about you to Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. The most damaging are missing payments and allowing your account to become so delinquent it becomes a collection account. Unfortunately, paying-off a collection account usually does not reverse the damage caused by your missed payments.

The two biggest credit score companies are FICO and VantageScore. About 90% of lenders use FICO. FICO does not notice if a collection account is paid or unpaid. VantageScore treats paid-off collection accounts differently. VantageScore ignores paid-off collection accounts, which reverses the damage caused by the delinquency.

Should I Pay or Ignore My Collection Account?

If a collection agent is pressuring you into paying a collection account, follow these four steps.

Two Collection Account Examples
Source: Bills.com
A collection agent contacts…
Facts …Sharon about a $650 debt she stopped paying 5 years ago …Tom about a $2,000 debt he stopped paying 2 years ago
Statute of Limitations 4 years in Sharon’s state 6 years in Tom’s state
Pay the debt? No legal obligation to pay because the SOL clock expired 1 year ago Tom may be obligated to pay the debt. He should validate the debt, and proceed accordingly.
  1. Validate the debt to make sure you really owe the debt. Just because a collection agent claims you owe a debt does not mean you do. Follow the directions on the page just mentioned to learn the steps to validate a debt properly. If the collection agent cannot validate the debt, it may not collect it.
  2. Learn your state’s statute of limitations to see if you have a legal obligation to pay the debt.
  3. If the time from your last payment on the debt to the present is longer than your statute of limitations, then you have a defense you can use if the original creditor or the collection agent file a lawsuit against you. In other words, you have no legal obligation to pay the debt.
  4. If the time from your last payment to the present is less than your state’s statute of limitations, then you cannot use the statute of limitations as a defense. In other words, you may have a legal obligation to pay the debt.

If the debt has not reached the end of your state’s statute of limitations, then consider negotiating a settlement to the debt.

When it comes to lawsuits, creditors are unpredictable. Some will file a small claims lawsuit for debts less than $500. It would be logical to assume creditors sue only people who have the ability to pay a judgment. However, Bills.com readers have reported creditors suing people with no income or assets.

Pay Debt to Improve a Credit Score?

If you see a collection account or two dragging your score down and you want to improve your score, then your options are limited.

Learn 7 techniques to improve your credit score. All of these techniques cost you little or nothing, are not gimmicks, and are based on information from FICO.

As mentioned, FICO will not increase your credit score when you pay-off a collection account. Because almost all mortgage lenders and many auto finance companies use FICO, paying-off a collection account will not increase the score lenders see.

Is it wasteful to pay-off a collection account? No, for three reasons:

  1. Your creditworthiness is more than a number. Lenders look at more than just your FICO score when determining your creditworthiness. Many lenders view paying off old debt as a sign of goodwill and trustworthiness. The lender looks beyond your score to see patterns of payments and commitment to financial obligations. A prospective lender likes to see a person who pays their debts, even if it notices a few bumps along the way.
  2. Your amount of debt matters. Lenders look at your debt-to-income (DTI) ratio as an important measure of your ability to repay a loan. Paying-off an old collection account will improve your DTI ratio and may make you a more attractive loan candidate.
  3. You avoid a lawsuit when you settle. If the statute of limitations has not run out on your collection account, the creditor can file a lawsuit against you. If it wins, the court will award it a judgment. The judgment will harm your credit score. The judgment creditor can use the judgment to garnish your wages, levy your bank accounts, place a lien on your property, and ask the sheriff to seize your personal property.

Visit the Bills.com credit resource page to learn more about credit scores and credit issues.

I hope this information helps you Find. Learn & Save.

Best,

Bill

Bills.com

People also like to Read

DC

Looking for credit card debt help? Review the 5 step plan for attacking credit card debt, compliments of Bills.com. Your firs...

MC

Need a loan for credit card consolidation or home repair? Read on to learn your options for secured and unsecured loan, plus ...

DC

Lexington Law Firm can help you remove inaccurate information on your credit report. You can do this yourself for free. Read ...

DC

Government Debt Relief | Compare government debt relief options that can help you save, including government mortgage relief ...

167 Comments

Recent Best
1500 characters remaining
  • SB
    Dec, 2014
    Sue

    Hi, I checked my credit reports, and I have to say I'm a bit dismayed and leary with the way GA Power is reporting the debit. The account is listed under the headliner closed account and in the comments section has a statement, collection account. Then for type of account it says open, single payment loan, and type of loan: utility loan. Date opened N/A and first delinquency 12/2012 and date of major delinquency 04/2013. This is debt for electric power bill. I never received mail or phone call or signed a note for a loan. GA Power does own a credit union. I believe GA Power does not have to comply with FFCA because they are the original holders of the debt. The balance is for over $1000. I'm wondering what would be the best way to proceed with the company? And is renaming the debt as a loan, is that normal? It just seems suspicious.

    0 Votes

    • DC
      Dec, 2014
      Daniel

      You have a right to dispute any inaccurate information that appears on your credit report. The debt is not a loan, so you could file a dispute to have the account listed properly. That being said, you don't seem to deny that the debt is yours and that the account went to collections, so your credit score is harmed however the account is listed.

      0 Votes

  • JC
    Dec, 2013
    Jay
    Will paying a collection account in full verses making a settlement for less than the entire balance make a difference to my credit score? I guess I'm asking if the notations "settled" or "paid in full" or some other phrase matters.
    0 Votes

    • BA
      Dec, 2013
      Bill
      We have not seen any statements from Fair Isaac & Co., the creator of FICO, or from VantageScore whether "paid as agreed," or "paid in full," or some other notation on a settled debt matters to your credit score.

      It is possible the wording might matter to a human loan underwriter reading your report. However, we hasten to add we have not seen any lender underwriting rules stating such.
      0 Votes

  • TR
    Dec, 2013
    Tony
    I paid off several collection accounts. This didn't increase my FICO score. I noticed that VantageScore gives you credit for paying-off old debts. How do I get my mortgage lender to use my VantageScore (650), which is higher than my FICO score (610)?
    0 Votes

    • BA
      Dec, 2013
      Bill
      Consumers do not get to choose which credit score lenders use. You mentioned a mortgage. Mortgage lenders use the "FICO classic" scoring model. The consumer credit reporting agencies call FICO classic different names:
      • Equifax Beacon 5.0
      • Experian/Fair Isaac Risk Model V2SM
      • TransUnion FICO Risk Score, Classic 04

      Why FICO classic? Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which buy almost all mortgages today, require loan officers to submit a FICO classic number, and do not allow VantageScore or other credit scores.

      0 Votes

  • ED
    Oct, 2012
    erin
    My credit score is 580, and I found out an old debt from over five years ago, totalling around $5000, is still showing up as being outstanding. I finally was able to get an official letter from the lawyer firm that garnished my wages until i paid what i had owed in-full. Who do i need to send this letter to, in order to raise my credit score, so that i can finally apply for a home loan??? Also, is my husband's bad credit going to affect me applying for the loan?
    0 Votes

    • BA
      Oct, 2012
      Bill
      Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, derogatory accounts may appear may appear on your credit report for up to 7 years from the date of first delinquency. Take a look at one of your credit reports by accessing AnnualCreditReport.com and find the date of first delinquency on the account in question. Add 7 years to the date of first delinquency, and that is when the debt will fall off your credit report. Your credit score should show some improvement at that point, assuming you have been paying your other accounts on time.

      If the account is showing a debt outstanding, and you paid the debt in full, then dispute the account with each of the consumer credit reporting agencies that report the incorrect account status.

      Both spouses do not need to apply for a mortgage. If your income and credit are sufficient to qualify for a loan on your own, your husband's bad credit will not be a barrier. If you need his income to qualify, then it will be a problem. See the Bills.com resource Mortgage When a Spouse Has Bad Credit to learn more.
      0 Votes

  • HS
    Jul, 2012
    Heather
    My credit score is 527. I have $6700 in collections. Most are unpaid medical bills, but $1800 of it is credit card debt (3 closed accounts). I would like to improve my credit score. In what order should I begin paying off this debt? Should I pay credit cards before medical bills, or age of accounts in general? Thank you.
    0 Votes

    • BA
      Aug, 2012
      Bill
      Paying off old, delinquent debts does not immediately greatly improve your credit score. The damage to your score that was done when the accounts become delinquent and then went into collections is not undone when the debts are paid. However, it is a positive factor to bring a debt to $0 balance. It does have a limited, good effect on your credit. More importantly, it eliminates the debt leading to a judgment that would further harm your credit and could be enforced by a wage garnishment or bank levy.
      0 Votes