Ask Bill your personal finance question

Best Debt Options

What is best debt consolidation option for us to get rid of our $20k in debt?

What is my best debt option to consolidate our $20,000 CREDIT CARD DEBIT. We have$160,000 in our 401K and approximately $10,000 in other IRA accounts. We own our home, appraised @ $250,000, OWE $120,000. Have $5000 cash. What is best way to get rid of the debt. Would not like to use 401K or draw equity from home. I am 50 years old. I earn 65,000 per year and spouse self employed in construction.  Please help me out Bill!

Read full question
Bill's Answer
(13 Votes) | Find Learn Save

  • There is no one size fits all best debt option.
  • First, try to refinance your mortgage and get the best rate in the marketplace.
  • If you are struggling financially, decide if credit counseling or debt settlement is best for your situation.

Thanks for your question on dealing with credit card debt and how to evaluate the best debt option.  There's no one singular best debt consolidation option for all consumers, but in your case you definitely have some options since you own your home with equity and have significant value in your retirement accounts.

First, regardless of how you choose to repay the debts, I would recommend that you pull the equity from your home with a refinance loan rather than taking the money out of your husband’s 401(k). The penalties associated with pulling money out of the 401(k) early rarely justify the benefits.  The one exception to that is if your company sponsored 401(k) allows for a 401(k) loan against a portion of your account value, since these are frequently low interest loans and much cheaper than your credit card interest rates.

As you mention in your question, there are significant penalties associated with drawing money from a 401(k) prematurely, along with an increased tax burden, which leads to most people losing around half of their money in penalties and taxes. Clearly, taking money from the 401(k) should be your last resort. To borrow money against your home, either through a home equity loan or a refinance loan, you will be required to pay lender fees and closing costs, along with interest, but these costs should be significantly less than had you borrowed the money from your 401(k) - and the interest is tax deductible.

If you want to apply - you may be a good candidate for a combination program of debt settlement and a refinance. In this case, you could refinance your home and take less cash out than you owe and then supply the funds to a company that will negotiate settlements on your behalf for much less than you owe. If, for some reason, you cannot qualify for a debt consolidation refinance loan, then you can explore debt settlement or credit counseling, but it sure does not sound like those solutions are best for your debt needs, since you don't really have a financial hardship.  However, if you want a free debt consultation with one of Bill's approved debt help partners, click here: Free Debt Relief Quote has created individual solution pages within the debt portal on credit counseling and debt settlement, but here is a quick summary of each one to get you started as well:

Credit Counseling

Credit counseling is a program that enrolls you on a debt management plan ("DMP") which usually allows you to qualify for a concession rate from your creditors for lower interest rates and lower payments. The plan should include reduced interest rates, lessons in budgeting and money management, or a comprehensive debt management program.

Debt Negotiation or Debt Settlement

Debt settlement services offer to negotiate and settle your debts for less than you owe, many times reducing debts by as much as half. Debt settlement is an option for people who cannot afford their monthly payments, and who are not worried if their credit rating will be negatively impacted during the program. It's important to be aware that you are NOT making monthly payments and staying current on your debts while enrolled in a debt settlement program, so be aware of the credit impact and the potential collection harassment from your creditors.

I wish you the best of luck in resolving your accounts. I hope that the information I have provided helps you Find. Learn. Save.



Get Debt Help!
(13 Votes)

People also like to Read

Brad Stroh

Debt Relief Options | Compare which debt relief option is best between Consumer Credit Counseling Services and Debt Settlemen... Read more >>

Brad Stroh

9 do-it-yourself debt solutions, including how to stop a collector's calls, validate debt, dispute an error in your credit re... Read more >>

Mark Cappel

Get Out of Debt Free | The lowest-cost method of getting out of debt for free is bankruptcy. You have other options, too, and... Read more >>

Daniel Cohen

Review your debt consolidation options. Find the right way to pay off your debt. Pay attention to debt consolidation reviews ... Read more >>

Mark Cappel

Learn about credit cards. Find low interest credit cards. Understand how to use credit cards to boost your credit. Make sure ... Read more >>


1500 characters remaining