Ask Bill your personal finance question

Can I Chose Between Original Creditor and Collection Agent?

My account is with a collection agency, can I negotiate with my original creditor instead?

I'm being sued on an account charged off in 2007. I dont trust the collection agency because of the many negative reviews, and complaints against it. Will I be able to contact the original creditor and pay them instead?

Read full question
Bill's Answer
(15 Votes) | Find Learn Save

A collection agent has a right to collect a debt regardless of its reputation.

In your case, it is impossible to say whether you will have success with contacting the original creditor and settling the debt directly. It's possible that the collection agent could be working on behalf of the original creditor to collect the debt on their behalf. If so, then you may be able to negotiate with the original creditor directly (but keep in mind this does not mean you will be successful).

On the other hand, if the collection agent bought the rights to collect on the debt from the original creditor, then it is now the creditor of record. In this case, there is no option of negotiating with the original creditor.

I suggest you read some tips about negotiating a settlement.

If you are being sued, whether you negotiate with the original creditor or the credit agent, you need to respond the summons. To read more about what can happen in the collection process I encourage you to read Collections Agencies, Collections Laws and Your State's Statute of Limitations.

I hope this information helps you Find, Save, and Learn.



(15 Votes)
Recent Oldest
1500 characters remaining
  • CV
    Greenville, IL,
    Dec, 2011
    I have 3 bad debt credit cards for about a year and a 1/2 and one has a judgment against me. All 3 have been through collection agencies. When i look at my credit report, it doesn't show any collections, just the oc charge offs. I want to bump my score up in like 2 weeks time and was looking at paying what I can in a lump sum and have the negative information removed. Do i deal with the oc or the collections agencies? Thanks, Chuck.
    • BA
      Jan, 2012
      If you have not received any letters from collection agencies and none show, then you have to start by contacting your original lenders. If they have sold off the debt, then they should be able to inform you who is holding on to it.

      Another suggestion is to get free credit report from and see who is listed as the most recent holder of the debt.

      You say that you want to improve your credit in two weeks. I believe that it will take longer than that.