Bills Logo

Mortgage Charge-Off & Foreclosure

Mortgage Charge Off and Foreclosure
Mark Cappel
UpdatedNov 28, 2023
  • clock icon
    4 min read
Key Takeaways:
  • Understand that an account that is charged-off does not mean the debt may not be collected later.
  • Negotiate with your lenders, to avoid foreclosure.

Should I negotiate with the banks that are foreclosing on the first and second mortgages on my home?

My home is in the final stages of foreclosure in Nevada. I had a first mortgage on the house with Countrywide/BofA. There is also a second mortgage HELOC with Charter One. I stopped making payments on both about 9 months ago. I continued to receive billing statements from Charter One, but about a month ago they updated my credit report as a Charge Off. I found this strange since the first mortgage holder has still not completed the foreclosure. I am sure that there will be no money available to pay the second lien holder, but found it curious that they would report as a charge off before the foreclosure sale. It has also been strange that I have never received a collection call or piece of mail from them trying to collect on the account in the last 9 months. I continued to receive the regular monthly statement until a couple months ago. How would you recommend that I proceed? Should I contact them to settle or let it ride for a while? The 2nd mortgage is for $37,500 and the first is for $352,000.

A mortgage is a written pledge of property used as security for the repayment of a loan. The property you purchase is the collateral for the mortgage. If you fail to make payments on the loan, the lender can repossess your home. As a result, the lender has some legal rights on your property as you pay off your mortgage.

Unlike a standard loan, the mortgage is used to enforce the lender's rights to the property if the borrower does not repay the home loan. If the borrower does not keep up with his/her monthly mortgage payments, the borrower can obtain the home through what is called foreclosure.

Mortgage charge off

I sense you may not fully understand what "charge-off" means. Charge-off is an accounting term used by creditors when they move a delinquent account from its accounts receivable books to its bad debt ledger. This usually occurs between 180 and 240 days from the date of your last payment. The fact that an account is charged off does not mean the debt may not be collected later. Charge-off is not required before a creditor initiates foreclosure. To understand more about the concepts of charge-off and why this term and event means almost nothing to debtors, see the resource Charge-Off & Credit Report.

Mortgage loan foreclosure

Foreclosure is the forced sale of a home or property that s pledged as security against a mortgage. The property is sold so the lender can recoup its losses on the loan.

There are two types of foreclosure: judicial and non-judicial foreclosure. A judicial foreclosure basically means that the foreclosure is a court-ordered legal process.

Learn more>> Each state legislature created unique foreclosure and anti-deficiency laws. Follow the links just mentioned to learn the foreclosure rules relevant to you.

Get Out Of Debt faster

See where your money’s going, make a smarter debt payoff plan, and get debt-free faster with the free Achieve GOOD™ app.

Learn more

Dealing with a Mortgage Charge-Off and Foreclosure: Exploring Your Options

Understanding your options is crucial in making informed decisions that could alleviate some of the pressures you're facing. Here's a brief look at the various paths you might consider:

  1. Communication with Lenders: Your first step should be to communicate with your lenders. They may offer modification options, forbearance, or other forms of assistance to help you manage your payments and avoid foreclosure.
  2. Loan Modification: This involves negotiating with your lender to modify the terms of your mortgage. Modifications can include reducing the interest rate, extending the term of the loan, or even reducing the principal balance.
  3. Refinancing: If you have enough equity in your home and a good credit score, refinancing could be a viable option. This could lower your monthly payments and make your debt more manageable.
  4. Forbearance Agreement: In some cases, lenders may agree to a forbearance plan, where they temporarily reduce or suspend mortgage payments. This is often a short-term solution to give you time to improve your financial situation.
  5. Short Sale: If you owe more on your mortgage than your home is worth, a short sale allows you to sell your home for less than the outstanding mortgage. This needs to be approved by the lender and can be a way to avoid foreclosure.
  6. Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure: This is where you voluntarily transfer the ownership of your property to the lender in exchange for release from your mortgage obligations. While it still affects your credit, it's less damaging than a foreclosure.
  7. Bankruptcy: Filing for bankruptcy might temporarily stop the foreclosure process. Chapter 13 bankruptcy, in particular, can allow you to keep your home and reorganize your debts.
  8. Legal Counsel: Get legal advice from a real estate attorney if you think there are problems with your mortgage or the foreclosure process.
  9. Government Programs: Investigate government programs designed to help homeowners in distress. Programs can offer refinancing, loan modification, or other forms of assistance to those who qualify.
  10. Credit Counseling: Seek advice from a reputable credit counseling agency. They can provide guidance on managing your debts and may offer solutions you haven't considered.

There are advantages and disadvantages to each option, and the best choice depends on your circumstances, like your financial situation, the value of your home, and your goals for housing. It's important to make decisions quickly and thoughtfully, as your choices can have long-term impacts on your financial health and credit

Bills Action Plan - Dealing with your mortgage foreclosure

Given the seriousness of your situation, with your home in the final stages of foreclosure, it's crucial to take immediate action.

  1. Engage with Your Lenders: It's essential to open a line of communication with both lenders. Inaction can lead to more complications, and negotiating might offer a pathway to a more favorable outcome.
  2. Seek Professional Advice: Consider consulting with a financial advisor or a lawyer who specializes in real estate and foreclosure. They can provide personalized advice based on your specific circumstances.
  3. Educate Yourself on Foreclosure Processes: Understanding your rights and options under Nevada's foreclosure laws is vital. This knowledge will empower you to make informed decisions. Check to see if bankruptcy or other foreclosure alternatives are practical.
  4. Explore Options for the Second Mortgage: Since the second mortgage is a significant part of your dilemma, it's important to understand the specific implications and options available to you. For detailed insights and guidance on handling a second mortgage foreclosure, visit's Second Mortgage Foreclosure.
  5. Consider Financial Implications: Be aware of the potential impact on your credit score and future financial opportunities. Any decision you make should factor in these long-term considerations.

You mentioned your home is "in the final stages of foreclosure." You later ask, "Should I contact them to settle or let it ride for a while?" The time to let things ride for a while is over if your goal is to retain your residence. Negotiate with both lenders now.

I hope this information helps you Find. Learn & Save.




aanne go, Nov, 2014

Great Post.

DDENA, Mar, 2014
I paid my last payment of $200 on a 36 month loan of $6000 at 12.01% interest. On occasion I paid the late fee if my payments werent paid by 25th. It was $25 and then $2 a day late fee. I paid all of my payments. He is still charging me 75 dollars every first of the month until I finish paying the late fees which now total over 400 dollars. How can he do this? His records aren't accurate at all. He only shows my payments of $200, doesn't have any dates that they were late, and doesn't include any of the times that I paid late fee on top of payment. I found out that I was paying too much late fee. The promissory note says that a late fee will be charged five days after due date, so instead of me calculating $25.00 on 25th and 2.00 a day after, I should have started that on the 30th. So, that's a good $10.00 he let me keep paying instead of informing me that I was paying too much. How can he show figures if he doesn't even have my payments documented right? I paid my last payment in September 2013 it is now April 2014 and he just keeps adding more and more late charges.
BBill, Mar, 2014
It sounds like you keep good records. Start by sending a letter to your creditor that shows all the payments you made. When you provide a clear record of the extra payments you made, there should be no trouble for your lender to credit you (not that there should have been a problem in the first place).

Request that 1. You only be charged for payments that met the late payment definition that was set out in your agreement. 2. That the credit reporting agencies receive accurate information about the status of your account.

Your letter should be polite but to the point. It is reasonable to state that if your reasonable requests do not receive timely action that you are going to contact a lawyer to assist you.

LLouise, Aug, 2011
I do not really understand this. If someone can explain, please reply. I bought a piece of property and paid (never late) on the loan for 3 years. Because of the economy and my husbands work became extremely slow, we had no choice but to "short sell" the property. Now, on my credit report, it shows a foreclosure and it has greatly affected my score. The bank said they reported it as a "charge off" Does anyone know the difference in all of these terms. The bank got paid, but not in full.
BBill, Aug, 2011
A foreclosure is a legal process where your lender forces the sale of your home that was used to secure your mortgage. A short sale is an alternative to a foreclosure, where your lender agrees to accept less than is owed and releases all liens on the property.

Are all three credit bureaus showing 'foreclosure'? If your lender agreed to a short sale, it should not be listed as a foreclosure on your report, especially if your short sale took place without your being delinquent on the loan.

Your credit report should show something like "settled as agreed," "account legally paid in full for less than the full balance," or "account settled."

Contact any of the credit bureaus that list 'foreclosure' and dispute the entry. If necessary, provide the bureaus with proof that you sold the house without it ever going into foreclosure.
JJudy, Apr, 2011
We purchased our property in 1999 on a land contract and refinanced twice since then. My name is only on the deed not the loan, loan is in my husband and we live in MI. In Oct 2010 we became 4 mos behind due to the modification and were pending foreclosure. Since then we have heard nothing from them and I decided to call Citigroup just to see what they had to say and the automated system said our balance was paid in full and they no longer service our mortgage. My husband and I decided to call and speak with someone live and I think we let the cat out of the hat. They said "our balance was 0 and why didn't we make any payments"? We explained that we thought they were foreclosing on the house but had not heard anything from them at all. They didn't say they would be foreclosing just transferred us to the recovery dept and afterwards a collections agency call my husband. Will we be able to keep the property since they have done nothing. I think if I wouldn't have called we could have keep our property. Can anyone tell me if the balance was paid or debt cancelled will they come after our home or should we just give it up. It really seem as though it a reason for all this. Is it because my name isn't on the loan and only on the deed and we live in michigan?
BBill, Apr, 2011
As your message (and similar messages from other readers) shows, the mortgage servicers are overwhelmed by foreclosures and modification requests, and as a consequence, files like yours fall through the cracks.

Whether you continue your ownership of the property depends on the deal you can reach with the recovery department/collection agent. Do you and your spouse have the income to make house payments?
BBill, Dec, 2010
Mike: I am a bit confused by your question about California Civil Code 608 because it discusses jury instructions in a civil trial. You may be thinking of California Civil Code 580b, which concerns California's anti-deficiency rules. Consult with a California attorney who has experience in civil litigation. You may need to file a pleading with a California court asking for a declaratory ruling regarding the status of the HELOC and the collection account on the first deed of trust.